We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
  • INDUSTRY PRESS ROOM
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
  • MEDIA FILE
  • Create Account
  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Newsletters
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • TRANSPORTATION
  • MATERIAL HANDLING
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFT TRUCKS
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • Webcasts
    • Blogs
      • One-Off Sound Off
      • Global Logistics and Risk
      • Empowering Your Performance Edge
      • Analytics & Big Data
      • Submit your blog post
    • Events
    • White Papers
    • Industry Press Room
      • Upload Your News
    • New Products
      • Upload Your Product News
    • Conference Guides
    • Conference Reports
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • DCV-TV
    • DCV-TV 1: News
    • DCV-TV 2: Case Studies
    • DCV-TV 3: Webcasts
    • DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
    • DCV-TV 5: Solution Profiles
    • Parcel Forum 2022
    • MODEX 2022
    • Upload Your Video
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • TRANSPORTATION
  • MATERIAL HANDLING
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFT TRUCKS
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • Webcasts
    • Blogs
      • One-Off Sound Off
      • Global Logistics and Risk
      • Empowering Your Performance Edge
      • Analytics & Big Data
      • Submit your blog post
    • Events
    • White Papers
    • Industry Press Room
      • Upload Your News
    • New Products
      • Upload Your Product News
    • Conference Guides
    • Conference Reports
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • DCV-TV
    • DCV-TV 1: News
    • DCV-TV 2: Case Studies
    • DCV-TV 3: Webcasts
    • DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
    • DCV-TV 5: Solution Profiles
    • Parcel Forum 2022
    • MODEX 2022
    • Upload Your Video
Home » CSA saga takes unusual twist as industry attacks FMCSA's "guidance" on safety measurement data
newsworthy

CSA saga takes unusual twist as industry attacks FMCSA's "guidance" on safety measurement data

May 31, 2012
Mark B. Solomon
No Comments

The ongoing battle between the federal government and motor carriers, brokers, and their customers over the government's controversial "Compliance, Safety, and Accountability (CSA) 2010" truck-safety rating program has taken an unusual turn.

On May 16, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), the sub-agency of the Department of Transportation that oversees truck safety, posted a slide presentation on its website that has generated controversy. The presentation is designed to provide shippers, freight brokers, and insurers with additional resources and guidance on how to use the "Safety Measurement System" (SMS) data embedded in CSA in order to determine a trucker's safety fitness.

Included in the notes accompanying two of the slides was language the program's critics say is a strong sign the agency wants to shed its statutory role as the final arbiter of highway safety and instead put the burden of evaluating a carrier's fitness on shippers and brokers. Such a change would expose both groups to significant liability risk should plaintiffs' lawyers show that their decisions contributed to injuries or fatalities resulting from an accident involving a motor carrier.

Under a 2011 legal settlement, the FMCSA affirmed its statutory obligation to conduct what are known as "Safety Fitness Determinations" of all DOT-licensed truckers. After conducting safety compliance reviews, the agency would rate each carrier as satisfactory, unsatisfactory, or "conditional," the last meaning the carrier would be allowed to operate but would continue to be monitored. Shippers and brokers interpreted the settlement to mean the FMCSA's authority would give them proper liability protection in the event of legal action arising from a truck-related accident.

But in the mid-May presentation notes, the FMCSA said that a "satisfactory or conditional rating does not mean ... that the public should ignore all other reasonably available information about the motor carrier operations." In another slide, the agency said that a "satisfactory" rating issued at the time of a prior compliance review "does not mean (a) carrier is currently in compliance and operating safely. A rating is only a snapshot based on the date of the most recent compliance review."

The Alliance for Safe, Efficient and Competitive Truck Transportation (ASECTT), a group of shippers, carriers, and brokers that is highly critical of the CSA process, said in a Web posting expected to appear today that the FMCSA's disclaimers indicate the agency "has now crossed the line" by stating that its safety ratings were relevant only at the time they were issued, and by advising shippers and brokers on how to use the SMS to make their own fitness determinations.

FMCSA has "abdicated its role as the ultimate judge of highway safety," ASECTT said in a two-page missive entitled "A Call for Action to Shippers and Brokers."

ASECTT also said the FMCSA has created a "constitutional crisis" by waiving the precepts of federal pre-emption "on its own motion in order to pursue the alleged benefits of 'raising the safety bar.' "

FMCSA officials said the information was compiled after meetings with leading industry groups, and that the agency was providing the industry with the tools needed to use the SMS data to help with carrier selection. In a statement, the FMCSA said it is "committed to working with the trucking industry, safety advocates, and other stakeholders to make (CSA) as effective as possible."

The agency recently extended until July 30 a public comment period on potential changes to the program, adding, "we want to take the time to get this right."

Industry groups call CSA flawed
Industry groups are skeptical, to say the least. The Transportation Intermediaries Association (TIA) said in a statement issued May 25 that safety ratings must be "retired" and replaced by what would effectively be considered a "thumbs-up, thumbs-down" determination by the agency.

TIA President Robert Voltmann said his group's biggest concern is that the data built into the SMS "will be misused, misunderstood, and cause a sweep of unnecessary and unfounded litigations against shippers and brokers."

The American Trucking Associations (ATA), which represents large trucking concerns, continues to endorse CSA's objectives but in recent months has grown increasingly concerned about what Rob Abbott, vice president of safety policy, called "numerous flaws" in the program.

"We met with FMCSA in April to present our list of concerns/solutions, but believe FMCSA is unlikely to address most of them," said Abbott in an e-mail.

Perhaps the most glaring flaw, in the ATA's view, is that truckers' scores in several of CSA's measurement components don't bear a strong relationship to future crash risk. In a May 11 letter to House-Senate conferees who are trying to hash out a new surface transportation reauthorization bill, ATA President Bill Graves said Congress should prevent the DOT from assigning safety-fitness determinations based on CSA scores until a proven link can be made between elevated CSA ratings and the carrier's likelihood of being involved in a crash.

Transportation Trucking Regulation/Government
  • Related Articles

    FMCSA restores CSA raw data to its website

    Will GAO report send FMCSA back to the CSA drawing board?

    Truck safety consultant casts doubt on FMCSA's carrier-grading proposal

Marksolomon
Mark Solomon joined DC VELOCITY as senior editor in August 2008, and was promoted to his current position on January 1, 2015. He has spent more than 30 years in the transportation, logistics and supply chain management fields as a journalist and public relations professional. From 1989 to 1994, he worked in Washington as a reporter for the Journal of Commerce, covering the aviation and trucking industries, the Department of Transportation, Congress and the U.S. Supreme Court. Prior to that, he worked for Traffic World for seven years in a similar role. From 1994 to 2008, Mr. Solomon ran Media-Based Solutions, a public relations firm based in Atlanta. He graduated in 1978 with a B.A. in journalism from The American University in Washington, D.C.

Recent Articles by Mark Solomon

Coming together for road safety: interview with Joshua Girard

Off the rails

Freight rate spikes shaking up the C-suite

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Most Popular Articles

  • Schneider welcomes first battery-electric truck

  • Fred Smith is not worried about Amazon

  • RJW LOGISTICS GROUP EXPANDS RETAIL LOGISTICS OPERATION TO DALLAS

  • Maersk deploys indoor drones for warehouse inventory counts

  • Outlook 2023: What’s in store for logistics/supply chain?

Now Playing on DCV-TV

5afe63a5 7125 4318 b851 1e5738df1c91

Patterson Fan Co. | HVLS V-Series Ceiling Fan | Staging Area Air Movement

DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
The Patterson V-Series is a high-volume, low-speed industrial ceiling fan that is designed to circulate a lot of air at a very low speed. These fans, ranging in diameters of 8’ all the way to 24’, are perfect for large, open spaces such as staging and shipping areas. One 24’ fan can generate a cooling effect of 6 –...

FEATURED WHITE PAPERS

  • The five best applications for robotic lift trucks in warehouse environments

  • Fulfillment Facility Improved Efficiencies by 4x

  • 3PLs: Complete Orders Faster with Flexible Automation

  • Reusable Packaging for the New Wave of Supply Chain Automation

View More

Subscribe to DC Velocity Magazine

GET YOUR FREE SUBSCRIPTION
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • NEWSLETTERS
  • ADVERTISING
  • CUSTOMER CARE
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT
  • STAFF
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Copyright ©2023. All Rights ReservedDesign, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing