Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

newsworthy

Fallout from Hanjin collapse to be amplified by complex web of ship alliances, experts say

Ripple effect to be felt by Hanjin's alliance members and their customers, experts warn.

On Sept. 2, the Port of Virginia, which runs terminals at Norfolk, Newport News and Portsmouth among other facilities, said it wouldn't transfer cargoes laden aboard ships of the bankrupt Korean liner Hanjin Shipping Co. to vessels in the "CKYHE" Alliance, a five-company global carrier compact that Hanjin belonged to. Nor would the port load cargoes from any of the four other members aboard Hanjin's ships, it said.

In a statement, the port said that it acted "after careful consideration" and at the behest of the four remaining carriers—Chinese carrier Cosco Group Container Lines, Japanese firm "K" Line, and Taiwanese firms Yang Ming Line and Evergreen Line. The port's actions underscore a key ripple effect of the largest bankruptcy in shipping industry: That the damage caused by Hanjin's collapse could stretch well beyond its customers and partners to affect users of other liner companies. These businesses may never have thought of booking their cargoes on Hanjin vessels, but due to the interlocking web of containership alliances, where carrier members swap vessel slots and move boxes around accordingly, that's where their goods ended up.


Such can be the blowback in the environment of ship alliances, which shippers, freight forwarders, and beneficial cargo owners (BCO) never much cared for, and will likely care for even less as the supply chain grapples with the collapse of the world's seventh largest liner company. Vessel-sharing agreements began in the mid to late 1980s as a way for carriers to improve capacity utilization and to defray the high cost of investing in large ships. They have become even larger in scope in recent years as the soaring costs of ever-larger ships needed to stay economically competitive made it difficult for an individual liner to invest outside of an alliance structure.

Liner interests maintain that their mode remains the most efficient mode for transporting global cargoes, and that the alliance structures continue to make this possible by using vessel assets as effectively as possible, and offering improved services to their customers.

However, shippers, BCOs and third parties have griped that the proliferation of alliances and the big ships that accompany them have strained port capacity, especially on the U.S. West Coast, causing shipment delays and backlogs.

The fallout from the Hanjin bankruptcy is likely to put unprecedented pressure on the alliance model. Hanjin contributed 21 vessels and nearly 177,000 twenty-foot equivalent unit (TEU) containers to the CKHYE alliance on the eastbound trades from Asia to the U.S. West Coast, according to data from U.K. maritime and logistics consultancy Drewry. On the eastbound Asia-East Coast trades, Hanjin contributed 13 vessels and about 84,000 TEUs, Drewry said. All told, Hanjin accounted for 8 percent of the container capacity of the eastbound trans-Pacific market, and 3 percent of global container capacity with about 600,000 TEUs.

Alan Murphy, CEO of shipping consultancy SeaIntel Maritime Analysis, told the U.K. publication The Loadstar that the impact of Hanjin's collapse would be felt by alliance partners and its customers, and by those involved in the many vessel-sharing agreements that operate in the non-alliance trades. "Shippers are likely to be surprised by the extent of such co-operation, and even though they are not customers of Hanjin they may still be heavily affected by the turmoil," Murphy was quoted as saying in the publication. The magnitude of the disruptions will largely depend on how quickly and effectively the CKYHE alliance carriers respond to the challenges, he added.

Simon Heaney, an analyst for Drewry, wrote late last week that while Hanjin's partners have begun to arrange for alternate means of transport, there will be "inevitable delays," especially for boxes that are stuck on the dozens of Hanjin ships that have been denied access to ports worldwide until it is determined who will pay ports and terminals to unload the cargoes. Shippers now moving their boxes from Hanjin to other carriers will face additional costs, while terminals will have problems moving containers to meet different vessels, as well as uncertainty over who will pay the handling fees, Heaney wrote. The remaining members of the CKYHE Alliance will have to fill the gaps left by Hanjin's exit, but such steps will disrupt its network scheduling for months, Heaney said.

Hanjin planned to leave the alliance early next year to join a new compact comprised of six carriers, including "K" Line and Yang Ming. Hanjin's demise is likely to diminish the competitiveness of the new alliance, said Heaney.

The Latest

More Stories

chart of GenAI effect on workforce

Gartner: GenAI tools create anxiety among employees

Generative AI (GenAI) is being deployed by 72% of supply chain organizations, but most are experiencing just middling results for productivity and ROI, according to a survey by Gartner, Inc.

That’s because productivity gains from the use of GenAI for individual, desk-based workers are not translating to greater team-level productivity. Additionally, the deployment of GenAI tools is increasing anxiety among many employees, providing a dampening effect on their productivity, Gartner found.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

warehouse worker driving forklift between racks

German 3PL Arvato acquires two U.S. logistics firms

The German third party logistics provider (3PL) Arvato this week acquired the U.S.-headquartered companies Carbel LLC and United Customs Services, saying the move would grow its client base, particularly in the fashion, beauty, and lifestyle segments.

According to Arvato, it made the move in order to better serve the U.S. e-commerce sector, which has experienced high growth rates in recent years and is expected to grow year-on-year by 5% within the next five years.

Keep ReadingShow less
photo collage of warehouse tech

Supply chain pros are wary of inflation and labor woes

The top worries that supply chain leaders hope to address with new innovations this year include inflationary concerns (68%) and labor shortages (50%), according to a survey on innovation from the third-party logistics provider (3PL) Kenco.

And many of them will have a budget to do it, since 51% of supply chain professionals with existing innovation budgets saw an increase earmarked for 2025, suggesting an even greater emphasis on investing in new technologies to meet rising demand, Kenco said in its “2025 Supply Chain Innovation” survey.

Keep ReadingShow less
volvo and waabi self driving truck

Volvo deepens partnership with Waabi for self-driving truck tech

Volvo Autonomous Solutions will form a strategic partnership with autonomous driving technology and generative AI provider Waabi to jointly develop and deploy autonomous trucks, with testing scheduled to begin later this year.

The two companies said they will integrate Waabi's virtual driver system, the Waabi Driver, into the Volvo VNL Autonomous, Volvo’s autonomous truck with redundant systems for enabling safe autonomous operations. The Volvo VNL Autonomous will be produced at Volvo’s New River Valley assembly plant in Dublin, Virginia, and be designed to support diverse operational needs, use cases, and Volvo Group truck brands.

Keep ReadingShow less
chart of women's portion of transport and storage jobs

Women hold only 12% of transportation and storage jobs worldwide

Women are significantly underrepresented in the global transport sector workforce, comprising only 12% of transportation and storage workers worldwide as they face hurdles such as unfavorable workplace policies and significant gender gaps in operational, technical and leadership roles, a study from the World Bank Group shows.

This underrepresentation limits diverse perspectives in service design and decision-making, negatively affects businesses and undermines economic growth, according to the report, “Addressing Barriers to Women’s Participation in Transport.” The paper—which covers global trends and provides in-depth analysis of the women’s role in the transport sector in Europe and Central Asia (ECA) and Middle East and North Africa (MENA)—was prepared jointly by the World Bank Group, the Asian Development Bank (ADB), the German Agency for International Cooperation (GIZ), the European Investment Bank (EIB), and the International Transport Forum (ITF).

Keep ReadingShow less