Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

newsworthy

Online returns activity proves adage that bad things can happen to good products

Millions of online returns have "no fault found" attached to product, RLA says.

As if retailers and manufacturers don't have enough challenges dealing with returns of products that don't work, they now have to cope with a growing volume of products that folks don't want.

The ordering ease and convenience spawned by online and mobile commerce has created an American "entitlement culture" that thinks nothing of returning stuff that is in otherwise perfect condition just because they simply didn't want it, according to Tony Sciarrotta, executive director of the Reverse Logistics Association (RLA). In 2017, e-commerce created 400 million package returns that would not have otherwise occurred. Of those, 80 to 90 percent were shown to have "no fault found," said Sciarrotta, using reverse logistics lingo to describe a non-defective product.


Consumers will return products ordered online—as they will do for store-bought items—because they are either disappointed with how they performed or because they changed their minds about the purchase. However, an increasing number of returns are effectively pre-ordained, and are conceived even before the consumer hits the order button to trigger the forward move. That's because consumers, knowing they won't be charged a shipping fee for returned items, feel free to order multiple sizes or versions of a product, keep all but one, and return the rest.

Not surprisingly, the percentage of returns of online orders is significantly higher than that of returns to traditional stores. According to RLA data from 2017, the e-commerce return rate was 18 to 25 percent, roughly three times that of brick-and-mortar stores. Online returns tend to run particularly high for clothing and shoe purchases because customers are especially likely to order several sizes to assure proper fit and style.

Sciarrotta told the SMC3 annual winter meeting in Atlanta Monday that returns account for between 7 and 11 percent of the cost of goods sold, but that the percentage is bound to go much higher as e-commerce inevitably takes a larger share of total retail sales. Currently, e-commerce composes about 9-12 percent of overall retail sales, depending on the source of the projection.

The reverse logistics process will be further complicated by what is projected to be a secular surge in demand for the Internet of Things (IoT), where products of almost every conceivable type will be digitally connected. Sciarrotta said the dizzying number of compliance standards for IoT deployment present a formidable challenge for those charged with processing returns.

Fortunately for retailers, many consumers still prefer to return items—even those ordered online—to stores. This provides several benefits to the retailers, according to Sarah Galica, senior director, reverse logistics, at Atlanta-based home improvement giant Home Depot Inc. It saves the retailer the costs of product pickup; it allows an unopened item to be re-stocked on the shelf or in store inventory for re-sale; and perhaps most important, it enables face-to-face feedback with the customer to determine what the problem was, a scenario that doesn't take place online, Galica said.

"A customer who's unhappy is more expensive for us than the cost of handling a return," Galica told the conference.

Last October, Seattle-based e-tailer Amazon.com Inc. began offering its merchants an option of allowing customers to keep items they might otherwise have returned, and still receive a refund. The theory behind Amazon's strategy was that it would save retailers the expense of processing returns, especially of relatively low-value goods, and would build customer goodwill by offering the flexibility of simply disposing of the product.

However, Sciarrotta of RLA said such a concept would be problematic for many retailers because they would lose the revenue opportunity of a potential re-sale. In addition, the program would be negative for the environment because it would add more junk to already-overburdened landfills, he said.

Ironically, technology—in the form of artificial intelligence (AI)—could play a role in mitigating online product returns by identifying consumer ordering patterns, and perhaps enabling retailers to guide consumers away from products that they had bought and returned before, Sciarrotta said.

The Latest

More Stories

Keepin' it fresh

Keepin' it fresh

Meal kit producer HelloFresh relies on automation to guarantee fresh and accurate shipments to customers—and that reliance has only increased as the company has grown from a small German startup to a global enterprise serving consumers in 18 countries. Surging demand, expanding menus, and the ever-present challenge of meeting high food quality and safety standards add complexity to the HelloFresh model, necessitating a focus on technologies that can give the business an edge as it grows.

Zeroing in on the U.S. market, company leaders took a leap nearly five years ago that would help HelloFresh meet burgeoning local demand and set the stage for further expansion of its menu and capabilities. They added a brand-new distribution center (DC) in Irving, Texas, that would feature the most advanced technology in the company's North American fulfillment network to date.

Keep ReadingShow less

Featured

instawork screen cap of warehouse worker profile

3PL LVK will partner with Instawork to find warehouse labor

The third-party logistics provider (3PL) LVK will partner with Instawork, whose app connects hourly professionals with local jobs, with the partners saying the move will answer a structural shortage of warehouse workers.

The deal will work by integrating LVK’s warehouse operations software with Instawork's network of vetted hourly workers, creating a lever to scale up warehouse operations across North America, they said.

Keep ReadingShow less
chart of consumer spending

Consumers “took a breather” on January spending after holiday rush

Shoppers spent less in January than they did during the busy holiday month before but retail sales had strong year-over-year gains nonetheless, according to the CNBC/NRF Retail Monitor, powered by Affinity Solutions, released today by the National Retail Federation (NRF).

“Consumers pulled back in January, taking a breather after a stronger-than-expected holiday season,” NRF President and CEO Matthew Shay said in the report. “Despite the monthly decline, the year-over-year increases reflect overall consumer strength as a strong job market and wage gains above the rate of inflation continue to support spending. We’re seeing a ‘choiceful’ and value-conscious consumer who is rotating spending across goods and services and essentials and non-essentials, boosting some sectors while causing challenges in others.”

Total retail sales, excluding automobiles and gasoline, were down 1.07% seasonally adjusted month over month but up 5.44% unadjusted year over year in January, according to the Retail Monitor. That compared with increases of 1.74% month over month and 7.24% year over year in December.

Likewise, the Retail Monitor calculation of core retail sales (excluding restaurants in addition to automobile dealers and gasoline stations) was down 1.27% month over month in January but up 5.72% year over year. That compared with increases of 2.19% month over month and 8.41% year over year in December.

NRF says that unlike survey-based numbers collected by the Census Bureau, its Retail Monitor uses actual, anonymized credit and debit card purchase data compiled by Affinity Solutions and does not need to be revised monthly or annually.

chart of trucking costs per mile

Uber Freight: Trump tariffs will likely be avoided after pause ends in March

As U.S. businesses count down the days until the expiration of the Trump Administration’s monthlong pause of tariffs on Canada and Mexico, a report from Uber Freight says the tariffs will likely be avoided through an extended agreement, since the potential for damaging consequences would be so severe for all parties.

If the tariffs occurred, they could push U.S. inflation higher, adding $1,000 to $1,200 to the average person's cost of living. And relief from interest rates would likely not come to the rescue, since inflation is already above the Fed's target, delaying further rate cuts.

Keep ReadingShow less
chart of US imports

NRF: Container imports remain high after Trump tariff threats

Days after tariff threats by the Trump Administration against Canada and Mexico were paused for a month, imports at the nation’s major container ports are expected to remain high, as retailers continue to bring in cargo ahead of the new deadline and to cope with elevated tariffs on China that did occur, according to the Global Port Tracker report released today by the National Retail Federation and Hackett Associates.

Part of the reason for that situation is that companies can’t adjust to tariffs overnight by finding new suppliers. “Supply chains are complex. Retailers continue to engage in diversification efforts. Unfortunately, it takes significant time to move supply chains, even if you can find available capacity,” NRF Vice President for Supply Chain and Customs Policy Jonathan Gold said in a release.

Keep ReadingShow less