We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
  • INDUSTRY PRESS ROOM
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
  • MEDIA FILE
  • Create Account
  • Sign In
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Free Newsletters
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • TRANSPORTATION
  • MATERIAL HANDLING
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFT TRUCKS
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • Webcasts
    • Blogs
      • One-Off Sound Off
      • Global Logistics and Risk
      • Empowering Your Performance Edge
      • Analytics & Big Data
      • Submit your blog post
    • Events
    • White Papers
    • Industry Press Room
      • Upload Your News
    • New Products
      • Upload Your Product News
    • Conference Guides
    • Conference Reports
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • DCV-TV
    • DCV-TV 1: News
    • DCV-TV 2: Case Studies
    • DCV-TV 3: Webcasts
    • DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
    • DCV-TV 5: Solution Profiles
    • Parcel Forum 2022
    • MODEX 2022
    • Upload Your Video
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Digital Edition
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • TRANSPORTATION
  • MATERIAL HANDLING
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • LIFT TRUCKS
  • PODCAST ETC
    • Podcast
    • Webcasts
    • Blogs
      • One-Off Sound Off
      • Global Logistics and Risk
      • Empowering Your Performance Edge
      • Analytics & Big Data
      • Submit your blog post
    • Events
    • White Papers
    • Industry Press Room
      • Upload Your News
    • New Products
      • Upload Your Product News
    • Conference Guides
    • Conference Reports
    • Newsletters
    • Mobile Apps
  • DCV-TV
    • DCV-TV 1: News
    • DCV-TV 2: Case Studies
    • DCV-TV 3: Webcasts
    • DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
    • DCV-TV 5: Solution Profiles
    • Parcel Forum 2022
    • MODEX 2022
    • Upload Your Video
Home » The 'Act of God' defense in freight claims disputes
newsworthy

The 'Act of God' defense in freight claims disputes

August 31, 2017
DC Velocity Staff
No Comments

(Editor's Note: An "Act of God" is generally defined as a sudden, unexpected, and unavoidable manifestation of the forces of nature. Federal and state law establish that a shipper cannot prevail in a freight claim against a carrier if an "Act of God" caused the loss, damage, or delay at issue. The defense is available to carriers of all modes in both domestic and international transportation.

In April 2004, Marc S. Blubaugh, attorney at the Cleveland-based transport law firm of Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff, published an article entitled, "The Perfect Storm: The Parameters of a Successful 'Act Of God' Defense in Freight Claims." In light of events of the past week, and the impact they will have for months to come, we have published excerpts from the article as it addressed the "Act of God" defense in claims cases involving hurricanes.)



The quintessential example of a successful "Act of God" defense arises in the context of weather: hurricanes, tornadoes, blizzards, floods, lightning storms, etc. These are generally considered to be "pure" events of nature. For instance, no amount of human ingenuity (or diabolical cunning) has yet succeeded in creating a hurricane, causing a tornado, or generating a blizzard. As a result, extraordinarily severe weather has often given rise to a valid "Act of God" defense. However, determining whether or not the defense is available in a particular case demands a much more nuanced analysis.

Of all severe weather phenomena, the hurricane distinguishes itself as perhaps the most intimidating of natural disasters. A hurricane can extend at any given time over hundreds of miles, contain winds upwards of 150 miles per hour, and deposit enormous amounts of precipitation in a very short period of time. One need only think of storms such as Hurricane Mitch, which killed more than 9,000 people in October 1998, to recall the truly devastating scope of a hurricane. Property damage, including damage to freight, accompanies every hurricane. Not surprisingly, the "Act of God" defense has been most heavily litigated in this context.

The case of "In the Matter of the Complaint and Petition of International Marine Development Corp." describes one of the clearest examples of a successful "Act of God" defense in the transportation arena. In this case, a variety of plaintiffs made claims for property damage and catastrophic personal injuries caused by Hurricane Camille. The court described the singular nature of the storm:

"Hurricane Camille, which was the greatest natural disaster in the history of the North American continent and caused more devastation and destruction to the Mississippi Gulf Coast and to the North American continent than any hurricane of record, with unprecedented wind velocity in excess of 200 miles per hour, a tide rise of 30 feet or more, and a tidal surge of at least 22 feet, is the most classic case and striking example of what is characterized as an Act of God. This freak of nature was of sufficient velocity and destructiveness to overcome all reasonable preparations..."

As a result, the court found that none of the claimants established liability as against the various defendants. The defendants prevailed as a matter of law on the facts at hand. In other words, the unique characteristics of this storm made this an easy case.

Similarly, in 1998 Hurricane Georges struck Mississippi, Alabama, and other nearby areas, causing a wide variety of property damage. In the case Skandia Insurance Co., Ltd. v. Star Shipping, a shipper brought a freight claim relating to several containerized, large rolls of paper that it owned which were damaged by the hurricane's floods. The court found that Hurricane Georges was a storm of such matchlessness and magnitude that it constituted an "Act of God":

"Notably, hurricanes, such as Hurricane Georges, are considered in law to be an "Act of God." Even though storms that are usual for waters and the time of year are not "Acts of God," a hurricane that causes unexpected and unforeseeable devastation with unprecedented wind velocity, tidal rise, and upriver tidal surge, is a classic case of an "Act of God."

The court found that the defendants in the case were protected by the "Act of God" defense in that they could not have prevented the loss with the application of reasonable foresight. The court gave particular significance to the timing and substance of weather advisories and the lack of prior floods in the geographic area. It should likewise come as no surprise that tornadoes often satisfy many of the factors relevant to a successful "Act of God" defense.

...The successful application of the defense turns on the severity of the event, the reasonable predictability of the event, the lack of human agency in the event, and the reasonableness of the carrier's precautions. One must perform the necessary historical research as well in order to have a context by which to judge the significance of the particular event in question.

Future developments in the application of this defense will undoubtedly occur as scientific understanding increases regarding the events that have historically constituted "Acts of God". However, as Albert Einstein once wrote "When the number of factors coming into play ... is too large, scientific method in most cases fails. One need only think of the weather, in which the prediction even for a few days ahead is impossible." In short, no matter how far science progresses, one can be certain that God will continue to serve up unforeseeable events.

Transportation
  • Related Articles

    Economy continues to cool, but danger of full freight recession dims, ACT says

    MercuryGate acquires freight claims management software firm

    New trailer orders in August were down 72% from a year ago, ACT says

Recent Articles by DC Velocity Staff

Artificial intelligence creates real encyclopedia

Freight sector missed the boat on strong U.S. economy in Q3 and Q4, FTR says

Sloppy thieves botch trailer heist

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Most Popular Articles

  • Fred Smith is not worried about Amazon

  • Outlook 2023: What’s in store for logistics/supply chain?

  • Ports, maritime operators see tide turning as ocean freight tsunami subsides

  • In Person: Steve Beverly of Penske

  • InPerson interview: Rob McKeel of Fortna

Now Playing on DCV-TV

Eeafd0c7 0569 4a63 8b31 fdbc5322c7cd

Crown’s DualMode Automated Forklifts Revolutionize the Warehouse

DCV-TV 4: Viewer Contributed
As part of the company’s ongoing digitization efforts, DHL Supply Chain has deployed Crown’s DualMode automated reach trucks to help ensure resiliency in the supply chain, with reach trucks available 24/7/365. “AGVs provide a better quality of life for our associates on the floor,” says Gordon Hanthorn, Senior...

FEATURED WHITE PAPERS

  • The five best applications for robotic lift trucks in warehouse environments

  • Fulfillment Facility Improved Efficiencies by 4x

  • 3PLs: Complete Orders Faster with Flexible Automation

  • Reusable Packaging for the New Wave of Supply Chain Automation

View More

Subscribe to DC Velocity Magazine

GET YOUR FREE SUBSCRIPTION
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • NEWSLETTERS
  • ADVERTISING
  • CUSTOMER CARE
  • CONTACT
  • ABOUT
  • STAFF
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Copyright ©2023. All Rights ReservedDesign, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing